Wednesday, February 22, 2017
Something about parenthood
I carry you now
Sunday, August 14, 2016
Back to work tomorrow
I also downloaded and installed the free, open-source software Inkscape. The idea behind this is I want to produce physics posts that include good-looking graphics, plus I want to avoid stealing images from other people: I'd sleep better making my own. From what I see at the gallery at the Inkspace website, the tool may be overkill for drawing pulleys and incline planes, but I want to try it out anyway. Another option that I have on the table is learning how to use the tikz and pgfplots pakages in LaTeX, which I'm familiar with. I feel that software like Inkscape could achieve many of the same results with a friendlier learning curve, though of course it would be suicide to use it for plotting mathematical functions. (I used good ol' Paint for some graphics in earlier posts, and was not too happy with the result. What I want is something that's easily usable like Paint, but with prettier results.)
Saturday, August 6, 2016
A week of reading and rest
Storm is a fascinating document, basically a polished diary of one German soldier's experience in World War I. I've encountered another version of this kind of literature before in All Quiet on the Western Front, by Erich Maria Remarque. I read that more than a year ago, and might re-read it soon, but I remember that that book is a much more "novelized" account of many of the same events. Unlike Remarque, Jünger passes no judgement of the causes of the war, nor does he mention any of the politics of the era at all. He simply tells what things happened to him, without much in the way of what he thought about them.
Both books left me amazed at the sheer amount of shelling that the war unleashed; it seems hardly a page goes by without "we came under heavy artillery fire". After a couple hundred pages of being under artillery fire (representing more than four years for Jünger) you wonder how it could be that anyone could survive the conflict and not be traumatized: just search YouTube for "world war 1 shell shock" and brace yourself.
I want to write a proper review of Storm of Steel, but I'm doing it in Spanish at my other site. For now, it is enough to state that it is a must-read for anyone interested in WWI, 20th Century history, or the combat experience in general. Accounts by historians are always useful, and I've read some myself, but Storm is a very polished primary source.
UPDATE 08/09/2016: the review is here (en español).
Sunday, July 31, 2016
July 31, 2016
Saturday, July 23, 2016
Thoughts for July 23, 2016
There's a saying among some comedians, which I think may itself be rooted in a quote from Oscar Wilde, that to be funny one must be telling the truth. Mexico has a myriad problems, from the daily life of its citizens all the way up to macroeconomic issues. But when one looks at international headlines, at least from the comfort of a middle-class PhD student, Mexico really isn't all that bad at all.
Europe is turning into a huge 1980's Beirut or, as some others have remarked, modern day Israel. There are now constant attacks by competing islamists against Jews (largely underreported), and ordinary citizens (especially women), not to mention the large-scale attacks like the ones in Nice last week. The Middle East, it seems, has found a way to make its troubles more horrifying and, on top of that, to export them. It doesn't help that Turkey is having an Islamic Revolution of its own, and may finally descend into full islamic theocracy soon. Syria is so bad that it's barely even reported anymore, except as a tally of dead and displaced that goes up every day. As I write this, there is news of a blast in Kabul, Afghanistan, carried out by ISIS militants against a Shia protest. To top everything off, the American election is one huge joke, with a competition between a plastic candidate that will change nothing and a dangerous, narcissistic idiot on the other.
So yes, Mexico is quite comfortable for now, from where I'm sitting (big caveat there!).
Saturday, July 16, 2016
Thoughts for the week, July 16
I can, however, explain a little bit of what I'm trying to do or, at least, what my professor has me working on at present. The idea is that, according to a proposed model of spacetime, we can have an elementary "cell" that divides into other spacetime cells, and those cells each divide as well, and so on. Each cell is a tiny, four-dimensional spacetime pyramid called a simplex. The way to keep track of the divisions is to keep track of the vertices, which is a lot easier, since each vertex is just a point. Simplex division in this case follows a specific set of rules: for example, the distance between any two vertices has to be greater than or equal to a minimum length, \(l\). This is the consequence of insisting that spacetime be quantized, which is the whole point of what CDT is about: we want to get tiny, indivisible chunks of spacetime that, when seen from far away, look like the smooth, continuous spacetime that GR describes.
My job, then, is to use computational methods to put a specific model of CDT to the test. The paper that outlines this model, sadly, is behind a paywall, but related papers on the physics arxiv are here and here. Anyway, here is a preliminary result:
I know, I know, it's not very impressive—but it took hours and hours of coding! An obvious remark would be that this is only a three dimensional spacetime, since that's what can be plotted in an image. This 3-D version of spacetime is a proxy for the real, 4-D thing that can't be visualized. The radius of the sphere that contains the vertices increases by a magnitude equal to the minimum length \(l\) at each step, and each step is a quantum "tick" of time. The mechanism by which the points divide is by "mating" with other points according to a specific operation and generating a new point at the new radius. All points mate with all other points, and the resulting points are located on the next sphere. This creates an enormous number of points that can't possibly fit on the surface of the sphere and maintain the condition that the distance between them is at least \(l\), so points are eliminated one by one until this condition is met (you can see the number of points in each stage at the top of the figure).
Friday, July 8, 2016
Weekly thoughts, July 8: Gun control
First, I find it scandalous that nothing has been done about the problem at all. One would think that even the most rabid gun nut would acknowledge that something has to be done, but they actually double down and insist on "the cost of freedom" or some other platitude, and sometimes simply quote the final four words of the Second Amendment, "...shall not be infringed!", as if that were a knock-down argument for any gun control. The trivial reply from someone like me would be, "well, then change what your stupid second amendment says!" It just seems incredible that, in the couple of decades that I've been paying attention, nothing has been done at all. Indeed, things have gotten somewhat worse since the assault weapons ban expired in the late 90's: yes, assault weapons account for only a tiny percentage of deaths, as most are due to handguns, but that's no consolation to the people in Aurora or Orlando. Yes, I understand how lobbying works and that the NRA does a lot of it; yes, I know there's a "gun culture" in the US that's different from that in some European countries with widespread gun ownership; yes, I know there are 300 million guns already out there and prohibition will create a black market and all of that; and yes, obviously some components of the problem are due to mental illness and religious terrorism; but still, the answer from Americans is we should do nothing?
From what I understand, most Americans actually do want to do something, like basic background checks before gun purchases and closing the gun-show loophole. But these things don't even get discussed at the political level because the gun nuts are very well organized in their lobbying via the NRA. I don't see Americans mobilizing en masse to do some effective lobbying of their own, as this would require a broad spectrum of warring groups in the culture war to cooperate extensively. Perhaps they could rally behind a strong presidential candidate with lots of political capital, but then that's not going to happen in this election. Over 30,000 annual deaths, plus the high-impact mass shootings we see every few months, have simply not been enough to get legislators to grow a pair and do something.
This sentiment of bewilderment at the situation is shared by most educated people in Mexico, though many laypeople who read of the latest mass shooting simply shrug it off with "Well, we all know Americans are crazy. So of course one of them would walk into an elementary school and kill 20 kids and their teachers at some point. That's just what Americans do." There is another strand of thought, if we could call it that, that seems to want to have something like the 2nd amendment here in Mexico. Gun ownership by citizens is regulated in theory, with citizens being able to own handguns up to a .38 caliber. Everything else is deemed "for exclusive use of the army." Very few Mexicans go through the hoops necessary to get legal ownership of a gun, though those hoops are purely bureaucratic and have nothing at all to do with training in the use of firearms.
In practice, Mexico is flooded with illegal guns, which come mostly from the US and are owned by the cartels. There have been cases of .50 caliber machine guns, grenades, and rocket launchers found in the hands of the narcos; they usually out-gun the police and sometimes even the army. Still, ordinary citizens tend to shy away from gun ownership, except for the small but growing group that I mentioned above: these people, usually right-leaning or anarchist, speak of "the people" taking arms and overthrowing the corrupt government, as they perceive that every other thing has been tried already and failed. There is also a strong current of vigilantism that advocates for citizens doing police work, as police in Mexico are generally regarded as worse than the criminals.
I don't think these Mexican NRA-types will have anything in the form of political success anytime soon, but I do worry about the vigilantism they inspire. There are already cases of mobs lynching suspected criminals, and there's no way that could get any better if the mobs were armed with guns instead of pitchforks. Politicians, especially at the local levels, have already been subject to attacks usually attributed to organized crime. I can't see how that would get any better if any Joe Schmo (or Juan Pérez, rather) could do the same as well. Domestic violence deaths, suicides, and accidents would obviously increase, too. I'm by no means a pacifist--I'm just squeamish about people self-righteously appointing themselves as "good guys with guns" with no one even writing their name down somewhere.
Friday, July 1, 2016
Weekly Summary: July 1, 2016
I’m done with chapter 3 in Carroll’s book, although I still have to go through the problems at the end. Some of these will be quite tricky, if the problems in previous chapters are any indication. I already got quite a workout from following the explanations in the text, as Carroll leaves lots of details up to the reader. In particular, I spent a couple of days trying to understand the derivation he makes of the Riemann curvature tensor, \(R^{\rho}_{\,\,\sigma \mu \nu}\). This tensor completely defines the curvature of a surface, and a space is geometrically flat when it equals zero. This tensor is one of the main players in General Relativity, and is defined as \[ R^{\rho}_{\,\,\sigma \mu \nu} = \partial_{\mu}\Gamma^{\rho}_{\sigma\nu}-\partial_{\nu}\Gamma^{\rho}_{\sigma\mu}+\Gamma^{\rho}_{\lambda\mu}\Gamma^{\lambda}_{\sigma\nu}-\Gamma^{\rho}_{\lambda\nu}\Gamma^{\lambda}_{\sigma\mu} .\]
I stole the image here from the Wikipedia article to ilustrate the concept of parallel transport: you start out with a vector at a point A, as in the picture, and keep the vector pointing along the path you follow along the surface (here, northward along a meridian on a sphere). If you then turn towards another path and make your way back to your starting point, you will find that on a curved surface the vector you dragged along has been rotated. This happens in surfaces that are intrinsically curved, and the Riemann tensor is a measure of that curvature. Typically, the strategy to derive \(R^{\rho}_{\,\,\sigma \mu \nu}\) is to imagine doing the parallel transport along an infinitesimal rectangular area, as is done in the book by Schutz. Carroll, however, goes for a more direct, but also much more abstract derivation: if you have the commutator of a covariant derivative acting on a vector field, you end up with a neat expression, after some work, that includes the Riemann tensor as part of the result: \[ [\nabla_{\mu},\nabla_{\nu}]V^{\rho} = R^{\rho}_{\,\,\sigma \mu \nu}V^{\sigma} – 2\,T^{\lambda}_{\,\,\,\mu \nu}\nabla_{\lambda}V^{\rho} .\]
The term \( T^{\lambda}_{\,\,\,\mu \nu} \) is the torsion tensor, which was previously introduced in the chapter. So what we have is that when taking the (covariant) derivative of a vector field in two different directions, it matters which direction you pick first. This only happens in curved spaces, where you end up with vectors being tilted with respect to the direction they had when they first started out. Carroll does the demonstration of this in three lines, and hand-waves a bit about how to get from one line to the next. So, I took it as practice to reproduce the derivation myself, and found I was successful, without the aid of the text book, after three attempts. Typing the whole thing would be impossible here, but fortunately I did take a picture (click to enlarge):
The definitions for the covariant derivatives of vectors and one-forms are in the box in the upper right corner, and the derivation begins on the upper left. On the lower left is just a reminder to myself of the definition of an anti-symmetrized tensor, which I used in the next-to-last line. The whole thing took about half an hour, with constant erasing and starting over at several points—as it should be. A valuable lesson, then, is that following the text and constructing the arguments yourself pays off in valuable practice; you can anchor your results in the steps that the author does show, and work out the entrails of the calculation yourself. As an added bounus, often times the end-of-chapter problems ask you to “fill in the missing steps in the derivation of equation X”, so you can tick problems off your set (indeed, I have been able to check many problems in Schutz’s book off my list this way).
Friday, June 24, 2016
Weekly summary: June 24
Anyway, the big news today is definitely Brexit, with a narrow majority of Brits voting to leave the EU. I don't know what to say about this, as Mexico isn't, and never has been, in a similar situation. From what I see on social media--particularly Twitter--people who voted to leave the EU are labeled de facto bigots, whereas people who voted to remain are branded as corrupt, self-hating authoritarians. What seems to be unambiguous is the dismay of the scientific community at the situation. The impact around the world will play out slowly over the next few months, but already there are warnings from experts of future financial and, potentially, political turmoil. For now, Mexican technocrats have used Brexit as an excuse to pass budgetary cuts--no one believes them, as always, and they go ahead anyway, as always.
Speaking of Mexico, the news out of the southern state of Oaxaca made headlines around the world and, as is usually the case anytime Mexico is noticed internationally, it was bad news. Teachers protested last weekend over an education reform that was passed a couple of years ago and has been phased into practice since. The crux of the issue is that the government insists that teachers need to be evaluated, but the teachers insist that the evaluation methods are extremely unfair and hurt teachers in poorer states and neighborhoods the most. Last Sunday, teachers protested and were met by riot police that had been waiting for them. The riot police were accompanied by hundreds of armed federal agents. Nobody knows who started the violence, but eventually shots were fired and eight people died; over a hundred more were wounded. Each side accuses the other of starting the violence, and there is no clear path forward at the time. Oaxaca is one of the poorest states in Mexico, and the teacher's union (known as the CNTE) is particularly strong there; there are frequent protests, especially around the month of May, when teacher's day is celebrated in Mexico. The CNTE union is known for its massive national mobilizations and month-long strikes in Oaxaca, and the educational reform has made them more upset than usual--rightly so, I think.
| Federal agents in riot gear confront protesters in Oaxaca, Mexico. |
Wednesday, May 25, 2016
On the Quantum God of the Gaps
Quantum Mechanics (QM) is part of a core of courses that all physicists take, no matter what their field. Obviously, people who specialize in QM will get into it a lot deeper than those that don't. There are some complicated areas of research going on right now, and there's plenty of debate going on--but the "basics", if we could call them that, are more than enough to refute just about everything Kurt said on episode 242.
First, the easy point: if you're going to take the approach "some smart guy believes X, so X is true" your're already in trouble because, as Bertrand Russell said, if you rely on an authority for your argument, there will always be other authorities who disagree. So if we were to tally the John Polkinghornes of the world as evidence that there could be a god hiding somewhere in QM--or free will, or the soul, or whatever--, then we would have to be intellectually honest and tally all the other guys who say he's full of shit as evidence that there's no such thing, which is everybody else. People in this latter camp include Sean Carroll, Lawrence Krauss, Richard Feynman, Tim Maudlin, Steven Weinberg, and many others. Polkinghorne is a theologian, so he's intellectually compromised by definition. This is not an ad-hominem: this is a simple statement of the fact that he can't be relied upon to be intellectually honest. If he were, he wouldn't be a theologian.
Now, on to actual QM: Just as in high-school algebra we had some complicated equation with numbers and letters, and we were asked to solve for "x", so too in QM there's an equation to solve, only mere algebra won't quite do the trick. This is the Schrödinger equation, which looks something like this: \[ i \hbar \frac{\partial \Psi}{\partial t} = -\frac{\hbar^2}{2m} \frac{\partial^2 \Psi}{\partial x^2} + V\Psi. \]
It may look complicated, but the idea is the same as in high school algebra: solve for the wave function, \(\Psi\) (greek letter "Psi"). After you do that, what you will get is an equation for \(\Psi\) that tells you what its value is in terms of x (position) and t (plain old time), plus some other physical constants and the specifics of your system (these are included in the V term above). Just as "x" was uniquely determined by all the other variables in high-school algebra, so too is \(\Psi\) determined--fully, for all time--by all the other squiggles in the Schrödinger equation. This is a second-degree partial differential equation and, with the right input, is fully deterministic.
The subtlety arises in the fact that \(\Psi\) is not a number, but a probability density, and that's where laymen get mixed up. Here is where an analogy will help and, if you were to remember any part of this post as particularly useful, this would be it. Imagine you have a fair die that you can throw. For any given throw, it's pretty hard to know what number is going to come up. Naively, one would think that the die coughs up a random number between 1 and 6 each time. However, if you throw the die many times, eventually you'll see a pattern: each number comes up roughly 1/6 of the time. That 1/6 is determined by the geometry of the die. No matter what individual result you look at--1,4,2,5,3,etc.--the 1/6 is always the same for every throw. That 1/6, roughly, is \(\Psi\). The geometry of the die is everything else in the Schrödinger equation. So even though any given throw is undetermined, the overall 1/6 is fixed for as long as the geometry is fixed.
Every experiment ever done confirms that the above equation, or some version of it, is true. If Kurt (or Polkinghorne, or whoever) wants to say that god is hiding somewhere in \(\Psi\), then they're making a claim that god can do no better that to show up as what probability theory would predict anyway without him, which seems like a pretty lame god to me.
As if that weren't enough, there's an entire field of research on hidden variable theory--the idea that there is a more fundamental, fully deterministic physics underneath the probabilistic character of the wave function. So the statement by Kurt, that it's just "a brute fact that QM is this way" is not obviously true either. Anyway, on to Gödel:
First, the necessary caveat: I'm a physicist, not a mathematician. With that said, Gödel's incompleteness theorems state that, for any given mathematical system based on arithmetic and axioms, there will be one of two inevitable outcomes: 1) there will be some theorems that will be true but unprovable, or 2) all theorems will be provable, but some will contradict others.
As an example, consider the sentence
"This statement is true".
Each word there is well-defined and fits the usual syntax to create a meaningful idea. You can think of each one of these words as an axiom (a basic assumption that doesn't need to be proven), and the syntax is the logic that is used to put them together and derive a theorem, which is a conclusion--the meaning of the statement itself. However, we can follow the same axioms and rules to construct a statement like this:
"This statement is false."
Each word there is well-defined, and all the words are arranged properly, but we can't decide on the meaning of the statement because the content of the statement refutes its logical construction!
Now, even though this is certainly important for the philosophy of mathematics, there is no way that you can get from it to the claim made by Kurt that some things are, and always will be, unknowable. That's a non-sequitur at worst, and a trivial argument from ignorance at best. A key distinction to keep in mind is that unprovable does not mean unknowable: remember, item 1) for the incompleteness theorems says "true, but not provable". In a way, this is part of what theoretical physics is about: there are some things we know are true (thanks to experiment) and we work to explain them--that is, to prove why it must be the case that they are true.
In any case, when people speak of god, they always mess up and fall into contradictions in the axioms themselves. Their conclusions are unsound because their premises are gibberish and the arguments never get off the ground--there are no theorems to be derived at all! This happens to all definitions of god that include omnipotence, for example. Once they include that as a basic assumption, the rest is white noise.
Thomas covered other many other areas of disagreement with Kurt on the show itself, and some commenters on the episode site have done so as well, so I'll leave it here for now. As a conclusion, I would say that people aren't smuggling contraband into QM (god, free will, the soul, consciousness) as much as they're smuggling it into their misunderstanding of QM. Sometimes, these people even have PhD's and published peer-reviewed papers. Bad ideas in science are weeded out eventually, but someone has to actually get on the ground and do it. This must be done by the experts, but it can be a slow, thankless process and so most of them just stay out of it and focus on their research; only a few jump in and get down and dirty. In the meantime, one has to be patient and wait it out.
Friday, May 13, 2016
I’m still alive!
So, my last post was a few months ago, which is a surprise to me, since I have felt as if I’ve only been away for a couple of weeks. Well, that’s what diving into General Relativity will do to you, I guess. Anyway, the point is I’ve been busy, but I’ve constantly thought of resuming regular posting on physics and all kinds of other things here. I’ve finally felt guilty enough to at least post this and, as I write, I don’t really know what to say other that I’ll do my best to neglect this blog a little less. (I’ve managed a handful of posts in my other blog, in Spanish, but even posting over there is too scarce for my taste as well.)
Most of the CUCEI campus is reing renovated, which means lots of dust all over the place, but the renovations will be worth it, as far as I can tell. For example, in order to get to the graduate physics building, I have to get through this:
The tiny gray structure behind the (brand new) yellow building is Building Z, where I and other graduate physics students dwell on campus. Other parts of CUCEI are quite lovely, and the students are quite peaceful and dedicated to their studies. Here are a few samples:
Also, I’ve made a somewhat successful effort to exercise. I jog for a few minutes on the track a few minutes’ walk from Building Z. Sometimes I can get a short run on three weekdays, though mostly I get one or two and another one on the weekend.
This track was just renovated as well, so I’ll be running on a nice new track starting next week.
Anyway, as far as actual physics goes, I’m almost done with a “first pass” over Relativity. I’ve used the textbooks by Lambourne, Schutz, and Carroll. Lambourne is surprisingly easy to digest, thought it may be too lenient for some people’s taste. Schutz is more like the usual modern approach to Relativity at the undergrad level, and Carroll is much more advanced and directed explicitly at graduates.
I’ve been assigned to write a short essay explaining de Sitter space for my Relativity course, and the text is pretty much ready (though in Spanish). If all goes well, I’ll resume posting here regularly quite soon, and I’ll use that essay as a crutch to get started. After that, I hope to resume topics on Classical Mechanics, and then work my way into other core subjects of graduate physics. Perhaps I’ll do asides on mathematical concepts as well, and many other topics that interest me (politics, religion, books, philosophy). This is a blog, after all, and I’m sort of making it up as I go along. In an ideal world with plenty of time and no procrastination, I would have a physics/math post and an unrelated post each week. I know I’m supposed to focus on my studies, but I just love writing and hate leaving for (possibly several years) later.
Wednesday, January 20, 2016
First week in PhD
The only problem was, when I got there last week, there was no knob on the door. After a couple of days, one was provided to me by our wonderful administrative assistant (secretary?)... but I had to install it myself. No big deal, but it was took some work because the door needed some light carpentry before the knob would fit. So here is the way it was before:
So after some light carpentry with tools a professor lent me, I laid out all the pieces of the disassembled knob and got it to fit into the door, after about 45 minutes of work:
Saturday, January 9, 2016
Start your engines!
So when I got to the CUCEI campus this Thursday, on the next-to-last day to get all the paperwork done, I found the admissions office with several dozen people already there, waiting in line:
Unfortunately for me, I had to make a stop at another office to turn in my files for my Master's degree first, which meant I would have to wait to get into the admissions line for a while. However, when I got to the degree office, they told me I needed a certificate from my undergraduate institution, which is ITESO. Also, I needed a more recent birth certificate, since the one I provided was more than three months old. And so, I had to leave and head to the Archivo (the Archive), as it's known by all in Guadalajara, and get a new birth certificate. It's one of the busiest public buildings in the city, with all kinds of people trying to get all kinds of documents for all kinds of purposes:
After that, I headed to ITESO to get the certificate, and I stopped to take some pictures along the way. It's one of the most peaceful, beautiful campuses anywhere in Mexico, and it was even greener than I remembered it from almost ten years ago, when I got my engineering degree there (click to enlarge):
When I finally got back to CUCEI and turned in the documentation to the degree guys, the admissions line had multiplied in length, and there was no way I would be able to turn everything in before they closed for the day at 3:00 p.m. (it was 2:30). I resolved to get back early the next day (the last day allowed) to finally turn all my documents in. Here is the line, pictured from left to right as it wraps around:
I finally turned in my documentation to the admissions office yesterday, after only a couple of minutes of waiting in line, and without any further requests from the staff. So I am now free at last to focus entirely on physics.
Monday, December 28, 2015
Classical Mechanics Primer
Now, the expression “not quantum” needs some unpacking. As an example, consider a toaster with a knob that you can turn at your leisure over some period of time, t. If you were to plot the energy flowing through the toaster’s resistance as you turn the knob, the graph that you will get might look something like this:
In Classical Physics, there is no limit to the number of times that you could zoom into any section of this plot, and every single time you would see a smooth, continuous line like the figure above. If you moved along the curve, you could always ride the line like a smooth ramp to any value of E that you liked, and in doing so you would pass through all points in between.
This is not the case in Quantum Mechanics, where many physical quantities are said to be quantized. In the toaster example above, the plot will look the same initially, but after zooming in a finite number of times, eventually you will reach a plot that looks more like this:
This is what makes Quantum Mechanics so weird. And so, Classical Physics includes all the branches of physics where this effect is not taken into account, regardless of when said branch developed. This includes theories such as Classical Mechanics, Electromagnetism, Thermodynamics, Fluid Mechanics, and General Relativity, among others. Usually, classical theories are an excellent approximation for all kinds of real world phenomena, even though the real world is actually quantized.
Newton
Newton’s Three Laws of Motion are as follows, though you may find some different wording depending on who you ask:
1. Objects move at constant velocity as long as there is no net force acting upon them. Velocity is not the same as speed, as it also includes direction and is therefore a vector quantity (usually notated in bold). Also, zero is a perfectly valid value for a constant velocity.
2. If there is a net force acting upon an object this will cause it to accelerate, according to the relation \(\mathbf{F} = m\boldsymbol{a}\).
3. Every action produces a reaction of equal magnitude and opposite direction. So if a certain object A pushes or pulls on B, B will answer with a push or pull of its own. This is usually notated like this: $$\mathbf{F_{AB}} = -\mathbf{F_{BA}}$$.The whole of Classical Mechanics emerges from these three laws, though by far the one used the most in calculations is the second one. At the high school level, this usually means doing lots of trigonometry for setups such as the following, which may distress some readers:
A typical problem in mechanics is to figure out the equation of motion of a body, given some initial conditions. We begin with some information about the object’s starting position, forces and constraints it is subjected to, and work our way up to the equation that will tell us how the object will actually move thereafter. In the case of Newton’s Second Law, all solutions are essentially variations on solving the differential equation $$ \mathbf{F} = m\mathbf{a} = m\frac{\mathrm{d} \mathbf{v}}{\mathrm{d} t}= m\frac{\mathrm{d} }{\mathrm{d} t}\frac{\mathrm{d} \mathbf{x}}{\mathrm{d} t}=m\mathbf{\ddot{x}}, $$ which would yield x as a function of t, or x=x( t ).
Unfortunately, most real world problems are not as clear cut as blocks on inclined planes, and Newton’s Laws are utterly impractical in their original formulation for solving anything but the most simple physical systems. Fortunately, there exist a couple of alternative approaches that manage to elegantly generalize Newton’s Laws so that they’re applicable to nearly any classical system one can think of, at the cost of introducing some abstraction. These approaches are absolutely equivalent to Newton’s Laws, and indeed incorporate them at their core, but their mathematical appearance is quite different.
Lagrangian Mechanics
If we think of space in three dimensions, then the position of a particle at any given moment can be described by a position vector from the origin, with individual components in the x, y, and z directions: \(\mathbf{r}=(x,y,z)\). The path that the particle will take over time will once again depend on the forces, constraints, and initial conditions it is subjected to. So, what we’re looking for is the way that \(\mathbf{r}\) will evolve over time, \(\mathbf{r}= \mathbf{r}(t)\).
However, working with cartesian coordinates (x,y,z) doesn’t help very much when, in general, physical systems aren’t easily describable by them. So instead, we introduce some abstraction and think of generalized coordinates, each of which we call \(q_{i}\). Each one of these coordinates could be cartesian \((x,y,z)\), cylindrical \((\rho ,\theta ,z)\), spherical \((\rho ,\theta ,\phi)\), or even other ways of placing a particle in space, such as a distance traveled along a constrained path, or an angle defined by the movement of a particle, or anything that suits us. Each generalized coordinate can also change in time, yielding a generalized velocity, and these are denoted using the dot notation for derivatives as \(\dot{q}_{i}\). By a simple extension, we can speak of other generalized quantities, such as generalized momentum \(p_{i} = \frac{\partial L}{\partial \dot{q}_{i}}\). This particular quantity will come in handy in later on.
A Lagrangian is defined as the difference of the kinetic and potential energies of the system in question, and it will have the following form: $$ L = \frac{1}{2}m\mathbf{\dot{r}}^{2}-U(\mathbf{r}).$$ The function U corresponds to the potential energy, and in general it will depend on the particle’s position. The first term is the familiar kinetic energy term \(\frac{1}{2}m\mathbf{v}^{2}\) from kindergarten, with the velocity expressed in terms of r.
Notice that the Lagrangian depends on the generalized coordinates and velocities, since each r is defined in those terms. L being a vector equation, we can separate the different \(q_{i}\)’s and their velocities into what are known as the Euler-Lagrange equations, which can be conveniently abbreviated as $$ \frac{\partial L}{\partial q_{i}} = \frac{\mathrm{d} }{\mathrm{d} t}\frac{\partial L}{\partial \dot{q_{i}}}. $$
So the rough strategy for solving problems in the Lagrangian formulation of Classical Mechanics is this: write L explicitly in terms of your generalized coordinates and velocities, making sure to include the specific (mathematical) description of U as well if it’s available. Then, plug the resulting expression for L into the Euler-Lagrange equation for as many coordinates as you have, perform the corresponding derivatives, and finally integrate whatever is left to solve each equation (i.e., get rid of whatever time derivatives are left over after you plug things in). If you’re successful, you will end up with as many equations of motion as you had generalized coordinates, and those equations of motion combine to give you the overall motion of the particle.
There are many nuances and neat things to go into with regards to the Lagrangian approach, but I’ll leave them aside for now. As a summary, notice that you end up with a second-order differential equation for each coordinate involved, and also notice that the setup for solving a problem begins with considerations of energy rather than forces. One important consequence of this is that any forces of constraint that may act on the object are naturally incorporated into the equations, without the necessity of force diagrams.
Hamiltonian Mechanics
A second approach to generalizing Newton’s laws is that of Hamiltonian Mechanics, which is a similar abstraction to that of Lagrange. First, we remember the concept of a generalized momentum, and also consider that for many systems the Lagrangian doesn’t depend explicitly on time $$\frac{\partial L}{\partial t} = 0.$$ When this is the case, we can define another quantity, the Hamiltonian, as $$H = \sum_{i=1}^{n}p_{i}\dot{q}_{i} – L.$$In addition, if the relationship between generalized and cartesian coordinates doesn’t depend on time either, the Hamiltonian is equal to the sum of the kinetic and potential energies of the system: $$H = T + U .$$In the same way that we used L in the Lagrangian formulation to derive our equations of motion, the Hamiltonian formulation relies on operating on H. In this case, the Hamiltonian is plugged into the equations $$\dot{q}_{i} = \frac{\partial H}{\partial p_{i}}\: ,\: \dot{p}_{i} = -\frac{\partial H}{\partial q_{i}}$$ to yield the equations of motion. This may seem like more work than the Lagrangian approach, but notice that we are left with sets of first-degree differential equations instead of second-degree ones. Even though we have twice as many equations as the Lagrangian approach, they are usually trivial to solve, and they include all the advantages of the Euler equations as far as dealing with constraints.
Hamiltonian mechanics in particular is important for later use in Quantum Mechanics and, as was the case with the Lagrangian formulation, there’s many details and asides that I left out for the sake of brevity. Both formulations are usually overkill for problems about blocks sliding down incline planes, but they become indispensable when working with more complicated systems. As I re-study mechanics for my PhD, I will try to post more on the details of each of these approaches, as well as practical examples of their use.
This post was the result of summarizing some of my notes on the subject, but obviously you would do well to look up these topics online. The Wikipedia entries are quite good, and then there are several recommendable textbooks. First, the Wiki links:
Newtonian MechanicsBooks that I’m familiar with include the following:
Lagrangian Mechanics
Hamiltonian Mechanics
1) Taylor, John R., Classical Mechanics. Great for undergraduate level students and laymen with calculus background. Informal, conversational style.
2) Goldstein, H. Classical Mechanics. Standard graduate text for students who want to get serious and be grown-ups. Very long-winded at times, but solid.
3) Landau & Lifshitz, Mechanics. Standard graduate text for masochists and people who like their textbooks lean and mean.
Saturday, December 26, 2015
Cross-post on atheism
God is not a good theory
Tuesday, December 22, 2015
Books, Books, Books!
As I mentioned earlier, I had ordered a few books in anticipation of my PhD studies starting next January. Two of the books in the order arrived today, and I'm quite giddy:
![]() |
| Tow out of four are here. |
![]() |
| Not too bad, huh? |
But wait, there's more! My wonderful sister, who's also quite a bibliophile, got me this little gem for Christmas:
![]() |
| Awesome! |
Speaking of next semester, the folks at admissions rejected my paperwork again... the amount of documentation one has to provide is of a Kafkian scale. I was livid last Friday when, after the guy had told me on Wednesday that all I needed was one more paper, and having procured it, he looked at the documents once more and said that I still needed even more documentation, and that I had to go three doors down the aisle (again) to begin another transaction. They're on break for the next two weeks, and I have only two more days, the 7th and 8th of January, to go over there again and finally finish the paperwork for good. After those dates I'm in trouble, because the admissions results have to be published in the university gazette on the 12th. Just writing about it is putting me in a bad mood, so I'll end here for now.
Thursday, December 17, 2015
Third World Problems
![]() |
| Sadly, this is not surprising. |
Rough translation (the grammar isn't very good in the original): Notice: On Thursday 17 operations will be from 12:00 to 15:00. Tomorrow, normal hours from 9:00 to 15:00. Sorry for the inconvenience. -Admissions.No explanations. The staff were just AWOL and left a note. When I got there, it was 11:50 and there were about 10 other people already there waiting. I had a doctor appointment at 13:00, and a 45 minute bus ride to get there, but I decided to hang on in case they showed up. Other people, who must have been there even earlier, left, and were now coming back, started to arrive. Soon, there were a couple dozen of us waiting. I waited until 12:10 and then left.
![]() |
| Fellow students who were "inconvenienced". |
This is not just an instance of what happens at CUCEI on a regular basis. This is what most of Mexico is like, especially in public institutions. For example, often this happens at the IMSS, our Third World attempt at a National Health Service. Only there, it's doctors who don't show up, or maybe they do but they don't have equipment or medicine. And people run into those situations often with pressing medical conditions, and they are told to go home and come back later (nearly every Mexican who can afford private health care ignores the IMSS altogether, even though they pay for it with their taxes. The number of Mexicans who can 'opt out' in this way is very small, and gets smaller every year, but that's a whole other essay.) Things have been slowly getting better over the past decade or two, but we're still decades behind the great country that we could be. And so, tomorrow I head over there again, and hopefully I can get the bureaucracy off my mind for the holidays.
Wednesday, December 16, 2015
Getting ready for the holidays
And so, in this digital age where all the information they need is already in some database that they own, it would be a matter of the admissions people logging on to some system, searching my name, and verifying that yes, indeed I got a degree in physics and it's certified by the folks three doors to their left. If they ever wanted the actual physical documents, then they could just ask those fellows for my name, and go over there and get them themselves. But no, it is I who has to request those documents (and pay for them!) and get them from one bureaucrat to the other one a dozen steps away. Most of Mexico works this way, I'm afraid.
In other matters, I've started a wonderful little book I ordered a long time ago in anticipation of a moment like now: A Student's Guide to Vectors and Tensors, by Dan Fleisch (I also own another great little book by him on Maxwell's equations). The first three chapters are a review me about vectors, but then things get novel when tensors are introduced. It's in these later chapters that I'll slow down considerably and do the excercises (he also has a supporting website, with all kinds of cool stuff to complement the text).
All of this is in anticipation of three other books that are more on-topic for my study. These could roughly be classified as being in a beginner, intermediate, and advanced level. I ordered them a coulple of weeks ago, and it's possible they'll arrive sometime before New Year's eve. They are the Relativity textbooks by Schutz, Carroll (whose website is featured in my blogroll), and Wald. There are many others, but I'm on a budget and I went for the most bang for my buck.
The semester formally begins on January 18, and I hope to have made some headway as far as learning some of the contents of the Fleisch text at least. Then things get interesting as I begin to work with my advisor and finally plunge head-first into the most beautiful theory ever devised that didn't end up in the trash bin immediately.
Wednesday, December 9, 2015
Paperwork-cracy
(Now that I think about it, I have to back up a bit for the sake of readers outside of Mexico. Public education in Mexico is virtually free all the way through undergraduate degrees; graduate level studies have a mostly symbolic hike in fees that's covered by many grants and scholarships and so it ends up being almost free anyway. How much is “almost free”? Try a tuition of $300 USD for a Master's in Physics per semester. The application fee for my PhD was about $60 USD. By contrast, a semester in a private university is at least $7000 USD in tuition. Remember, average per capita income in Mexico is less than $20,000 per year.)
It was when I made the switch to the public system, first in music and then in physics, that I sometimes felt like I was the one who was shallow and fake. Everybody was there because they actually wanted to, and they were good, hard working people. I'm in touch with almost nobody from my private education years—especially classmates from high school, who I mostly despised then, and still do. Some friends from engineering linger in my social media, but it's mostly my public school friends that I cherish the most and stay in touch with.
One point against public education, however, is the awful amount of paperwork that one has to do for everything. Among the documents I have to produce to complete my PhD application process, I have to submit a copy of each of the following:
- Master's Degree
- Master's Thesis Defense Certificate
- Master's Studies Certificate
So I have to spend time (and some money) procuring three documents that amount to the same thing: that I was a competent physicist at the Master's level. These papers have virtually the same information printed on each of them. One wonders how it could be that, in the digital age, I have to produce hard copies of each when the university itself owns a few. After my Master's, I didn't bother to do the paperwork so they could hand me my actual degree, mostly out of procrastination, all I got was the Thesis Defense Certificate. The procedure takes a few months and, because I have to procure these documents by January 18, I now have to get another document requesting an extension. Private institutions are way ahead in this regard, and I can remember how my passage through engineering was a breeze as far as administrative paperwork went.
Besides this awful tramitocracia ("paperwork-cracy"), I want to devote the few weeks I have left as a relatively free man to review some tensor analysis, but also to just relax, read a book or two, and watch videos on YouTube for the Holiday season. If the tensor analysis goes well, I may have time to do a piece on the basics of tensors, so that we can actually get started on real physics.
Wednesday, December 2, 2015
In the beginning
But now I was stuck having to confront Dr. K., having finally made up my mind that I would attempt to get into the PhD program. Since finishing my Master's more than a year earlier, I had my sights set on making up for my weaknesses by studying relentlessly before even trying to enter the PhD program, in order that I could work on what really interested me, which was General Relativity. Another professor, Dr. N., had already pretty much accepted me as his pupil, despite my best efforts to prove my incompetence to him (more on this later). But now I had to take the formal step of approaching Dr. K. and officially declaring my intention to enter the PhD candidate pool to him.
“So what did you work on for your Master's?” he asked. His Russian accent was noticeable, but much more subtle than Dr. N.’s.
“Astronomy, with Dr. R.”, I said.
He immediately responded, “Yes, but what actual physics did you work on?”
I wasn't expecting this. You see, astronomy is a branch of physics, and I had worked on spectroscopy. That seemed like physics to me, and so I told him.
“Spectroscopy? Well, then. Tell me about the physics of spectroscopy.”
I rambled and stuttered through the principles at work, mostly butchering the explanation of atomic energy levels, emission of photons in the mid-infrared portion of the spectrum, how they corresponded mostly to molecular hydrogen, how they were then captured by the spectrograph on a space telescope, and how I used a Boltzmann distribution to deduce the energy and therefore the temperature of the hydrogen. . . I trailed off, and his expression somewhat begrudgingly acknowledged there was some physics in what I was trying to say.
“So what do you know about Relativity? Have you worked on it before?”
I mumbled something, but before I could go on he interrupted and asked, “Do you know what a Killing vector is?”
I was blank. “Uh, no,” I said.
“And what is the Schwarzschild metric?”
I knew that one, but couldn't find the words quickly enough. There was an interruption. A student entered the office and discussed some result or calculation with Dr. K. for a few minutes. After he left, he returned to me:
“Look, this is my off-the cuff impression. I'm not judging you, and I don't know you, but what you want to do is very risky. Relativity is really difficult. If you haven't worked with it before, you're not going to get to a high level and produce meaningful results in 3 years. You're setting yourself up for failure,” he said, “You're an engineer, right?”
Dr. N. must have told him something about me, but I had no idea how much had been said. I confirmed I had a degree in chemical engineering, from many years ago. Then I explained—–attempted to explain–—that I had already made my best effort to tell Dr. N. that I didn't feel ready, but that he insisted that I sign up for the entrance exam and interview anyway. I also said Dr. N. had given me some papers to read, and had basically accepted me as his student already, even though the exact topic of my research wasn't yet defined specifically. I mentioned I had good programming skills, and that I could study and learn on my own. He shook his head slightly at this, somewhat dismissively.
“The work Dr. N. does is very advanced mathematically. I don't think you're ready if you come from astronomy. He's been my friend for many years, but we haven't spoken about your case in detail. Are you sure he said he's accepted you?”
I nodded. We got into a brief conversation about how I got to Dr. N. in the first place, how I was interested in Relativity but open to working on something else, and how Dr. N. had advised me to work on what I really wanted rather than what would be easiest or more realistic. I described how I had gone through all the points on the entrance exam study guide one by one with Dr. N., and how I had failed miserably, but Dr. N. told me not to worry about it and just make sure I understood the basic principles at work—–I had about a month to study up. He had said that the panel of professors took many factors into account during the examination, and being a robot that remembered all the equations wasn’t going to win me many points if I didn’t have certain other traits that they looked for in a candidate. Dr. K. seemed very conflicted at this point, keeping his gaze down, and it was mostly me who did the talking. He mentioned the possibility of looking up another astronomy professor and working on a PhD with him instead.
“Look, I encourage you to take the exam. I really do. But you must reconsider your field of study. On the day of the exam, you must have your decision made. Really, take the exam,” he said, “But reconsider. If Dr. N. has already agreed to work with you, I won't get in the way. But honestly I think it would be a dangerous mistake.”
So that's what went around my head at that moment and the rest of the day (and night). Not the excitement of finally reaching a milestone I aimed at since childhood, nor even the stuff that I was supposed to study up on over the next month, but rather the idea that all along I'd been setting myself up for failure by making mistake after mistake after mistake, only to plow along anyway and potentially be miserable for the next three years, if I even made it that far.


















